WV Supreme Court: Fairmont hospital can appoint board members - WOWK 13 Charleston, Huntington WV News, Weather, Sports

WV Supreme Court: Fairmont hospital can appoint board members

Posted: Updated:
Photo courtesy of the West Virginia Supreme Court Photo courtesy of the West Virginia Supreme Court
  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • UPDATE: All Northbound lanes open on I-77 at East River Mountain Tunnel

    UPDATE: All Northbound lanes open on I-77 at East River Mountain Tunnel

    Saturday, July 26 2014 6:42 PM EDT2014-07-26 22:42:00 GMT
    All northbound lanes are back open after a tractor trailer that caught fire inside the East River Mountain Tunnel on Friday. It happened in the northbound lanes of the tunnel that divides Mercer and Bland around 2:00 Friday afternoon.
    All northbound lanes are back open after a tractor trailer that caught fire inside the East River Mountain Tunnel on Friday. It happened in the northbound lanes of the tunnel that divides Mercer and Bland around 2:00 Friday afternoon.
  • Sistersville Woman Crowned Mrs. West Virginia, Will Compete for National Title

    Sistersville Woman Crowned Mrs. West Virginia, Will Compete for National Title

    Tuesday, July 15 2014 4:17 AM EDT2014-07-15 08:17:38 GMT
    A Sistersville mother, wife, and soon-to-be teacher, holds another very impressive title as she gets ready to take on the competition on a national stage.Mrs. West Virginia, Melissa Smith, will compete for the title of "Mrs.United States," in September. Smith travels throughout the state right now helping to push her platform. "Right now, I'm very focused on improving literacy education. I'm going to be an elementary school teacher and I have been traveling throughout West Virginia reading to...
    A Sistersville mother, wife, and soon-to-be teacher, holds another very impressive title as she gets ready to take on the competition on a national stage.Mrs. West Virginia, Melissa Smith, will compete for the title of "Mrs.United States," in September. Smith travels throughout the state right now helping to push her platform. "Right now, I'm very focused on improving literacy education. I'm going to be an elementary school teacher and I have been traveling throughout West Virginia reading to...
  • Federal judge in Martinsburg, West Virginia, sends 10 to prison for violating probation

    Federal judge in Martinsburg, West Virginia, sends 10 to prison for violating probation

    Sunday, July 6 2014 11:00 AM EDT2014-07-06 15:00:12 GMT
    Nine Martinsburg, West Virginia, residents and another from Keyser were sentenced to federal prison for breaking the law while they were on supervised release or probation.
    Nine Martinsburg, West Virginia, residents and another from Keyser were sentenced to federal prison for breaking the law while they were on supervised release or probation.
  • LawMore>>

  • WV Tax Institute to host annual meeting

    WV Tax Institute to host annual meeting

    Sunday, July 27 2014 8:30 AM EDT2014-07-27 12:30:01 GMT
    The West Virginia Tax Institute’s 65th annual meeting will be Oct. 19-21 at Canaan Valley Resort in Davis, West Virginia.
    The West Virginia Tax Institute’s 65th annual meeting will be Oct. 19-21 at Canaan Valley Resort in Davis, West Virginia.
  • WV Bad faith case archive launched

    WV Bad faith case archive launched

    Saturday, July 26 2014 3:00 PM EDT2014-07-26 19:00:27 GMT
    Martin Seibert LC has launched a West Virginia Bad Faith Case Archive, an educational resource devoted to cataloging West Virginia insurance bad faith case law.
    Martin Seibert LC has launched a West Virginia Bad Faith Case Archive, an educational resource devoted to cataloging West Virginia insurance bad faith case law.
  • McDowell magistrate removal petition dismissed

    McDowell magistrate removal petition dismissed

    Saturday, July 26 2014 7:30 AM EDT2014-07-26 11:30:07 GMT
    A judicial tribunal has dismissed a petition calling for the removal of McDowell County Magistrate Steve L. Cox.
    A judicial tribunal has dismissed a petition calling for the removal of McDowell County Magistrate Steve L. Cox.

Fairmont General Hospital, not the city or the council, has the authority to appoint its board members, West Virginia Supreme Court justices recently affirmed.

The per curiam opinion was filed June 5 in the case of Fairmont General Hospital v. City of Fairmont and Fairmont City Council.

The city owned Fairmont General from 1938-1985 and during that time, the city charter held the hospital's board would have 11 members appointed by the council and two of them would be council members.

In 1985, Fairmont General became a nonprofit corporation, filing its own articles of incorporation and bylaws, which held board members would be appointed by the council.

This practice of the council appointing board members and two members being council members went on for 25 years, the opinion states.

However, in 2010, Fairmont General amended its bylaws so its board could appoint other members, even though the amendment was inconsistent with the articles of incorporation.

The next year, Fairmont General appointed two people to its board and the council appointed two people to sit on the board, basing its decision on the city charter.

Fairmont General refused the council's appointees and sought declaratory judgment and an injunction.

The city and council alleged the hospital's decision to appoint new members and refuse the council's appointees violated the articles of incorporation and state laws, court documents state.

Fairmont General amended its articles of incorporation while the lawsuit was pending, the opinion notes, but the city and council wanted the court to find the amended articles void.

The Marion County Circuit Court judge ruled the city and council did not have standing to challenge Fairmont General's actions and that the city charter did not apply because the hospital is no longer city-owned.

Justices ruled the city and the council do not have standing to challenge Fairmont General Hospital and cannot base such a challenge on the city charter since the hospital is no longer municipally governed.

"Putting aside the fact that FGH is not ‘owned by a local government,' as everyone in this case concedes, there is not one word in the statute mandating — or even suggesting — that municipal officials should sit on a nonprofit hospital's board of directors as ‘members of the community,'" the opinion states.

"We reject the underlying assumption, which is not supported by any evidence in the record, that non-council appointees to the hospital's board are likely to run amok and abandon an institution that has existed for 75 years," the opinion additionally stated.

Spilman Thomas & Battle attorney Michael S. Garrison, who represented Fairmont General, said he was pleased the hospital could operate outside of city government.

"This is a significant win for FGH and it adds to Spilman's solid history of helping clients eliminate impediments to their success," he said in a released statement.